Rubric Results 2023 Listing of Comments & Scores

4704

Clinic / Performance

20

4704

Clinic / Performance

48

This appears to be a submission of only one piece of music that is quite short. I don’t think this would be a good fit for the convention

4704

Clinic / Performance

22

I am not sure what the clinic portion will be about. It sounded like they plan to perform one piece, and I am not sure how that can fill the entire time slot. A description of the clinic portion would have helped me envision their idea better. Upon hearing their video, I would have loved to hear more about what Latin and African roots it draws from, because it did not sound extremely latin or african to me.

4704

Clinic / Performance

24

They signed up for a clinic, but in the description talk about the new piece they're going to play. This might be better suited for the New Music showcase. They can clearly play, but I'm not sure this category is correct.

4704

Clinic / Performance

32

4704

Clinic / Performance

83

May consider for in-person or virtual for clinic/performance. There are other applications with steelpan but this one is number two for me. The artists are good and well-experienced educators too.