Rubric Results 2023 Listing of Comments & Scores

4591

Clinic / Performance

0

4591

Clinic / Performance

66

This duo looks very creative, especially with their use of creative Brazilian percussion instruments. It seems the clinic portion of this submission is less clear, and would be stronger if it had more structure and pedagogical implications (i.e. what are they teaching the audience about what they are playing?)

4591

Clinic / Performance

42

I am not sure what their clinic will be about. The performance portion does have a lot of good detail. Perhaps they are going to teach what they will perform? Their video was good. The topic might be too similar to other applicants' this year, and I am not sure theirs was the strongest application.

4591

Clinic / Performance

14

I think this group would be better suited for the New Music performance showcase. It seems they want to showcase their original music and not necessarily give a clinic.

4591

Clinic / Performance

56

This has some interesting and original ideas but it's not clear what will be presented with regards to the "clinic" part of this proposal.

4591

Clinic / Performance

69

Good for virtual PASIC or in-person but under new music/ research committee.