Rubric Results 2023 Listing of Comments & Scores

4525

Professional Development

51

4525

Professional Development

65

4525

Professional Development

22

This looks like an advertisement.

4525

Professional Development

60

Great outline, interesting to explore the intersection between build and playing technique

4525

Professional Development

16

4525

Professional Development

63

4525

Professional Development

66

Interesting intersection of industry and artistry. The description is very good. I like that it's an international company too. I'm not sure I've ever seen anything like this at PASIC.

4525

Professional Development

40

Advertisement

4525

Professional Development

32

Appears to be a cymbal company commercial.

4525

Professional Development

16

4525

Professional Development

44

4525

Professional Development

20

This clinic session seems a little too focused on presenting a specific brand's products. I am all for a cymbal clinic and techniques on how to get the best sounds. A session in which a company is essentially talking up their products seems to undermine the credibility of a session at PASIC.

4525

Professional Development

52

4525

Professional Development

76

4525

Professional Development

37

This feels like an ad for the company more than an educational clinic based on the description.
Actual educational content isn't well described.
Might be more focused on material science than music education.

4525

Professional Development

40

4525

Professional Development

87

This is an interesting proposal, but I wonder how much specific company product we should be pushing? Obviously the information about the making of the cymbals and design would be incredibly interesting, but it seems like a product pitch.